Muhakkima

Muḥakkima (Arabic: محكّمة) and al-Haruriyya (Arabic: الحرورية) refer to the Muslims who rejected arbitration between Ali and Mu'awiya I at the Battle of Siffin in 657 CE.^[1] The name Muḥakkima derives from their slogan lā ḥukma illā li-llāh (لا حكم إلا لله), meaning "no judgment (hukm) except God's".^[1] The name al-Haruriyya refers to their withdrawal from Ali's army to the village of Harura' near Kufa.^[1] This episode marked the start of the Kharijite movement, and the term muḥakkima is often also applied by extension to later Kharijites.^[1]

In recent times, some adherents of Ibadi Islam, which is commonly identified as a moderate offshoot of the Kharijite movement, have said that the precursors of both Ibadism and extremist Kharijite sects should be properly called Muḥakkima and al-Haruriyya rather than Kharijites.

History

According to al-Shahrastani, an 11th AD century Shafiite scholar, the proto-Kharijite group were called al-Muhakkima al-Ula.^[2] They were rooted in the caliphate horsemen that existed in the times of Muhammad.^[3] The al-Muhakkima al-Ula group were led by a figure named Dhu al-Khuwaishirah at-Tamimi,^[4] more famously known as Hurqus ibn Zuhayr as-Sa'di, a Tamim tribe chieftain, veteran of the Battle of Hunayn and first generation Kharijites who protested the war spoils distribution.^[3]^[5]^[6]^[7]^[8] According to several Hadiths, Hurqus was recorded being prophesied by Muhammad that he will revolt against the Caliphate later.^[9]

At first, Hosts of Hurqus were among those who participated in the Muslim conquest of Persia led by Arfajah, Rashidun general who commands the army and navy in Iraq. During Conquest of Khuzestan, Hurqus defeated Hormuzan in 638 at Ahvaz (known as Hormizd-Ardashir in modern era) to subdue the city.^[10] However, later during the reign of Uthman, Hurqus was one of the ringleaders from Basra that conspired to assassinate Uthman.^[9] They are the soldiers of Ali during the battle of Siffin, who later rebelled towards the Caliphate of Ali and planned their rebellion in the village of Haruri.^[2]

The host of Hurqus also contained another Kharijite embryos that hail from Bajila tribe,^[11] which led by Abd Allah ibn Wahb al-Rasibi, who later became founder of Ibadi group.^[12]

Battle of Siffin

During the Battle of Siffin, Mu'awiya proposed to Ali to settle their dispute through arbitration, with each side appointing referees who would pronounce judgment according to the Quran.^[1] While most of Ali's army accepted the proposal, one group, mostly from the tribe of Tamim, vehemently objected to the arbitration, seeing it as setting human judgment above God's word.^[1] They expressed their protest by proclaiming that "there is no judge but God and there is no judgment but God's" (lā ḥakama illā-llāh, wa-lā ḥukma illā li-llāh.^[13] or lā ḥukmu illā li-llāh^[14]) This is a reference to the verse fal-hukmu lillah, Quran 40:12.^[15] From this expression, which they were the first to use, they became known as al-muḥakkima, or al-muḥakkima al-ula (lit. the first Muḥakkima).^[13] The term may have originally referred ironically to their rejection of arbitration, since the word muhakkim means "arbiter".^[16]

Later developments

The initial group of dissenters, including Hurqus ibn Zuhayr as-Sa'di,^[17] went to the village of Harura near Kufa, where they elected an obscure soldier named Abd Allah ibn Wahb al-Rasibi as their leader.^[1] This gave rise to their alternative name, al-Haruriyya.^[1] Other defectors from Kufa, where Ali's army had returned awaiting the outcome of arbitration, gradually joined the dissenters,^[1] while Ali persuaded some dissenters to return to Kufa.^[18] However, when the arbitration ended in a verdict unfavorable to Ali, a large number of his followers left Kufa to join ibn Wahb, who had meanwhile moved his camp to another location along the Nahrawan Canal.^[1]^[18]

At this point, the Kharijites proclaimed Ali's caliphate to be null and void and began to denounce as infidels anyone who did not accept their point of view.^[1] From Nahrawan, they began to agitate against Ali and raid his territories.^[18] When attempts at conciliation failed, Ali's forces attacked the Kharijites in their camp, inflicting a heavy defeat on them at the Battle of Nahrawan in 658.^[1] This bloodshed sealed the split of the Kharijites from Ali's followers, and Kharijite calls for revenge ultimately led to Ali's assassination in 661.^[1]^[19]

On a larger scope, remnants of Hurqus' group of the Muhakkima al-Ula or the Haruriyya proto-Kharijites who had survived the battle of Nahrawan would later influence the splinter sects of Azariqa, Sufriyyah, Ibadiyyah, Yazidiyyah, Maimuniyyah, Ajaridah, al-Baihasiyyah, and the Najdat radical sects.^[2]^{[Notes 1]} These violent warrior sects would plague the entire history of the Rashidun, Umayyad, and Abbasid Caliphates with endemic rebellions.

The egalitarian Kharijite doctrine brought about by the Sufrite branch preachers even also found homage among the flocks of Berber soldiers due to their largely unequal treatment under the Caliphate,^[20] Thus inciting the Great Berber Revolt which weakened the Umayyad Caliphate to certain degree. ^[21]

Etymology of Muhakkima

The followers of ‘Alī who departed from his army in protest over the arbitration were named Muḥakkima after their cry lā ḥukma illā li-llāh. The verb ḥakkama signifies, amongst others, this principle which means to judge, to decide and the verbal noun taḥkīm, a judgment or decision. The participial noun muḥakkima is formed from this verbal noun and denotes collectively all those who proclaim this principle, lā ḥukma illā li-llāh (لا حكم إلا لله). The unity of the followers of ‘Alī was sundered in the crisis of the second fitna (64/683) when it split into three main schools, with the extremist Azāriqa and the moderate Ibadis at opposite poles and the Sufris somewhere in between.^[22]

Beliefs

The early dissenters wished to secede from Ali's army in order to uphold their principles.^[19] They held that the third caliph Uthman had deserved his death because of his faults, and that Ali was the legitimate caliph, while Mu'awiya was a rebel.^[19] They believed that the Quran clearly stated that as a rebel Mu'awiya was not entitled to arbitration, but rather should be fought until he repented, pointing to the following verses:^[19]^[18]

If two parties of the faithful fight each other, then conciliate them. Yet if one is rebellious to the other, then fight the insolent one until it returns to God 's command. (Quran 49:9)

Fight them until there is no fitnah (temptation), and religion is wholly unto God (Quran 8:39-40)

The dissenters held that in agreeing to arbitration Ali committed the grave sin of rejecting God's judgment (hukm) and attempted to substitute human judgment for God's clear injunction, which prompted their motto lā ḥukma illā li-llāh (لا حكم إلا لله, 'judgement belongs to God alone').^[18] They also believed that Muslims own allegiance only to the Quran and the sunna of Muhammad, Abu Bakr, and Umar, and denied that the right to the imamate should be based on close kinship with Muhammad.^[19] These beliefs found expression in their departure from Ali's army.^[19]

Khaled Abou El Fadl writes,

Anecdotal reports about the debates between 'Ali and the Khawarij reflect unmistakable tension about the meaning of legality and the implications of the rule of law. In one such report members of the Khawarij accused 'Ali of accepting the judgment and dominion (hakimiyya) of human beings instead of abiding by the dominion of God's law. Upon hearing of this accusation, 'Ali called on the people to gather around him and brought out a large copy of the Qur'an. 'Ali touched the Qur'an while instructing it to speak to the people and inform them about God's law. Surprised, the people who had gathered around 'Ali exclaimed, "What are you doing? The Qur'an cannot speak, for it is not a human being!" Upon hearing this, 'Ali exclaimed that this was exactly his point. The Qur'an, 'Ali explained, is but ink and paper, and it does not speak for itself. Instead, it is human beings who give effect to it according to their limited personal judgments and opinions. [... In] the historical context, the Khawarij's sloganeering was initially a call for the symbolism of legality and the supremacy of law that later descended into an unequivocal radicalized demand for fixed lines of demarcation between what is lawful and unlawful.^[23]

Saba'iyya

Aside from the name of al-Muhakkima Muslim scholars and chroniclers also coined a name of Saba'iyya towards the group as derogatory nickname, which means "the followers of Abdullah ibn Saba'.^[2] As Muhammad Sa'id Roslan, Egyptian Salafi cleric explained the medieval Islamic scholars associate the early Kharijites who killed Uthman as those who follow Abdullah ibn Saba'.^[24]

Ibadis and Kharijites

Both Muslim and non-Muslim scholars tend to refer to Ibadis as "moderate Kharijites",^[25] and Ibadis are commonly identified in academic sources as an offshoot of the Kharijite movement, which broke away from more extremist Kharijites currents in the late 7th century CE.^[26]^[18]^[1]^[27] Most scholars identify Kharijites as those who seceded from Ali's army because of their rejection of arbitration.^[28] Ibadis have traditionally used the adjective Wahbi (referring to Ibn Wahb al-Rasibi) to describe their denomination and strongly identified with ahl al-Nahrawan (the people of Nahrawan).^[28] Until recently, some Ibadis also identified Ibadism as a sect of Kharijism.^[28] During the 20th century, Ibadis moved away from sectarianism and favored a rapprochement with Sunni Islam.^[29] Over time, Ibadis grew uncomfortable with the Kharijite label,^[27] and contemporary Ibadis strongly object to being classified as Kharijites.^[25] In their objections, some modern Ibadi authors point to the differences between Ibadi doctrine and some of the more extreme beliefs commonly associated with Kharijites.^[29] The Ibadi scholar Nasir ibn Silayman al-Sabi'i has argued that the precursors of Ibadis should be called al-Muḥakkima and al-Haruriyya, and that the first clear use of the term khawarij (Kharijites) as a proper noun appears only after the split of Ibadis from more extremist Kharijite sects.^[29]

References

Notes

^ Sunni Muslim scholars agreed that Yazidiyyah and Maimuniyyah were the most deviant among all Kharijite sects according to Islamic Iman doctrine, as they have further different concept of prophet in Islam and Qur'an. Thus, according to Prof. Dr. Muhammad Isa al-Hariri were the reasons the jurists and scholars of Islam to brand the Yazidiyyah and Maimuniyyah as true Kafir (Heretic in Islam)^[2]

Sources

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l ^m ⁿ Levi Della Vida, G. (2012). "K̲h̲ārid̲j̲ites". In P. Bearman; Th. Bianquis; C.E. Bosworth; E. van Donzel; W.P. Heinrichs (eds.). Encyclopaedia of Islam (2nd ed.). Brill. doi:10.1163/1573-3912_islam_COM_0497.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e Irham Zuhdi & Abidun 2015, pp. 399–423
^ ^a ^b Kenney 2006, p. 26.
^ Kenney 2006, p. 28.
^ Timani 2008, p. 09.
^ al-Sallabi, Ali (2017). "Orientalism and Islamic history" (Ebook). Biography of Ali Ibn Abi Talib. Darussalam Publishers. p. 151. ISBN 9786035001670. Retrieved 20 December 2021. ... thereafter to become a distinguished leader of the Khawarij. However, it is mentioned in a narration that his name was Hurqus and the name of his father was unknown. In another narration it is claimed that his name was Malik, ...
^ Szigorich, Thomas (2009). Violence and Belief in Late Antiquity Militant Devotion in Christianity and Islam (Hardcover). University of Pennsylvania Press, Incorporated. p. 210. ISBN 9780812241136. Retrieved 23 December 2021. ... during their own rebellion.38 In the late seventh century , the Sufriyya Khariji sect would trace their communal lineage through a series of earlier Khawarij back to two of the martyrs of Nahrawan , Dhu Thafinat and Hurqus b .
^ M. Ahrari, Ehsan (2017). The Islamic Challenge and the United States Global Security in an Age of Uncertainty (Ebook). McGill-Queen's University Press. p. 317. ISBN 9780773548367. Retrieved 20 December 2021.
^ ^a ^b Subani 2013, p. 44.
^ Jalalipour 2014, p. 7.
^ Donner 2014, p. 196,197,342
^ Kenney (2006), p. 41, calls him "the first ‘Kharijite’ caliph".
^ ^a ^b Djebli, Moktar (2012). "Taḥkīm". In P. Bearman; Th. Bianquis; C.E. Bosworth; E. van Donzel; W.P. Heinrichs (eds.). Encyclopaedia of Islam (2nd ed.). Brill. doi:10.1163/1573-3912_islam_SIM_7311.
^ Dan Cohn-Sherbok (1997). Hick, John (ed.). Islam in a World of Diverse Faiths Islam in a World of Diverse Faiths Library of Philosophy and Religion. Springer. p. 158. ISBN 1349253243. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
^ Shaykh Seraj Hendricks. The Kharijites and Their Impact on Contemporary Islam 1.
^ Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. p. 197.
^ Sizgorich, Thomas (2009). Violence and Belief in Late Antiquity: Militant Devotion in Christianity and Islam. University of Pennsylvania Press. pp. 206–207. ISBN 0812241134. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f John Alden Williams; Justin Corfield (2009). "Khawārij". In John L. Esposito (ed.). The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Islamic World. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195305135.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Francesca, Ersilia (2006). "Khārijīs". In Jane Dammen McAuliffe (ed.). Encyclopaedia of the Qurʾān. Brill. doi:10.1163/1875-3922_q3_EQCOM_00103.
^ J. T. Brown 1963, pp. 11–16
^ Clarke 2013, p. 510.
^ Wilkinson, John C. (2014). "Ibadism. Some Reconsiderations of its Origins and Early Development". In Ziaka, Angeliki (ed.). On Ibadism. Germany: Georg Olms Verlag AG. p. 43. ISBN 978-3-487-14882-3.
^ Abou El Fadl, Khaled (2004), Cohen, Joshua; Chasman, Deborah (eds.), Islam and the challenge of democracy, Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press, ISBN 978-0-691-11938-0
^ Hakim, Saifudin (2021). "Mengenal Pokok-Pokok Aqidah Kaum Khawarij (Bag. 1)". Muslim.or.id (in Indonesian). Muslim.or.id. Retrieved 20 December 2021. Diraasaatun fil Bid'ati wal Mubtadi'in by Dr. Muhammad Sa'id Ruslan
^ ^a ^b Hoffman, Valerie Jon (2012). The Essentials of Ibadi Islam. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press. ISBN 9780815650843.
^ John L. Esposito, ed. (2014). "Ibadis". The Oxford Dictionary of Islam. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Archived from the original on August 20, 2017.
^ ^a ^b Keith Lewinstein, Racha (2013). "Ibadis". In Gerhard Böwering; Patricia Crone (eds.). The Princeton Encyclopedia of Islamic Political Thought. Princeton University Press.
^ ^a ^b ^c Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. pp. 187–188.
^ ^a ^b ^c Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. pp. 193–195.

Bibliography

Clarke, Nicola (2013). "'They are the most treacherous of people': religious difference in Arabic accounts of three early medieval Berber revolts" (PDF). EHumanista. 24: 510–525. Retrieved 18 October 2021.
Donner, Fred M. (2014-07-14). The Early Islamic Conquests. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-1-4008-4787-7.
Irham Zuhdi, Masturi; Abidun, M. (2015). Ensiklopedi Aliran dan Madzhab Di Dunia Islam [Encyclopedia of sects and Schools in the Islamic World; Arabic:Silsilah al-mawsu'at islamiyahmutakhasshihah; mausu'ah al-firad wa al-madzhahib fi al-alam al-islam] (in Indonesian). Pustaka al Kautsar; Tim Riset Majelis Tinggi Urusan Islam Mesir (Egyptian Islamic Affairs High Council Research Team). pp. 399–423. ISBN 978979-5926948. Retrieved 8 December 2021.
J. T. Brown, William (1963). Kharijite Political Influences in Medieval Berbery. University of Wisconsin--Madison. pp. 11–16. Retrieved 8 December 2021.
Jalalipour, Saeid (2014). The Arab Conquest of Persia: The Khūzistān Province before and after the Muslims Triumph (PDF). Sasanika.^{[permanent dead link]}
Kenney, Jeffrey T. (2006-10-12). Muslim Rebels: Kharijites and the Politics of Extremism in Egypt. Oxford University Press, USA. ISBN 978-0-19-513169-7.
Subani, Hamad (2013). The Secret History of Iran. Lulu.com. ISBN 978-1-304-08289-3.
Timani, Hussam S. (2008). Modern Intellectual Readings of the Kharijites. Peter Lang. ISBN 978-0-8204-9701-3.

[20] Sunni Muslim scholars agreed that Yazidiyyah and Maimuniyyah were the most deviant among all Kharijite sects according to Islamic Iman doctrine, as they have further different concept of prophet in Islam and Qur'an. Thus, according to Prof. Dr. Muhammad Isa al-Hariri were the reasons the jurists and scholars of Islam to brand the Yazidiyyah and Maimuniyyah as true Kafir (Heretic in Islam)^[2]

[EI2-1] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l ^m ⁿ Levi Della Vida, G. (2012). "K̲h̲ārid̲j̲ites". In P. Bearman; Th. Bianquis; C.E. Bosworth; E. van Donzel; W.P. Heinrichs (eds.). Encyclopaedia of Islam (2nd ed.). Brill. doi:10.1163/1573-3912_islam_COM_0497.

[Ensiklopedi_Aliran_dan_Madzhab_Di_Dunia_Islam-2] Irham Zuhdi & Abidun 2015, pp. 399–423

[FOOTNOTEKenney200626-3] Kenney 2006, p. 26.

[FOOTNOTEKenney200628-4] Kenney 2006, p. 28.

[FOOTNOTETimani200809-5] Timani 2008, p. 09.

[6] -Sallabi, Ali (2017). "Orientalism and Islamic history" (Ebook). Biography of Ali Ibn Abi Talib. Darussalam Publishers. p. 151. ISBN 9786035001670. Retrieved 20 December 2021. ... thereafter to become a distinguished leader of the Khawarij. However, it is mentioned in a narration that his name was Hurqus and the name of his father was unknown. In another narration it is claimed that his name was Malik, ...

[Violence_and_Belief_in_Late_Antiquity_Militant_Devotion_in_Christianity_and_Islam-7] Szigorich, Thomas (2009). Violence and Belief in Late Antiquity Militant Devotion in Christianity and Islam (Hardcover). University of Pennsylvania Press, Incorporated. p. 210. ISBN 9780812241136. Retrieved 23 December 2021. ... during their own rebellion.38 In the late seventh century , the Sufriyya Khariji sect would trace their communal lineage through a series of earlier Khawarij back to two of the martyrs of Nahrawan , Dhu Thafinat and Hurqus b .

[8] M. Ahrari, Ehsan (2017). The Islamic Challenge and the United States Global Security in an Age of Uncertainty (Ebook). McGill-Queen's University Press. p. 317. ISBN 9780773548367. Retrieved 20 December 2021.

[FOOTNOTESubani201344-9] Subani 2013, p. 44.

[FOOTNOTEJalalipour20147-10] Jalalipour 2014, p. 7.

[Donner_3-11] Donner 2014, p. 196,197,342

[FOOTNOTEKenney200641-12] Kenney (2006), p. 41, calls him "the first ‘Kharijite’ caliph".

[EI2-tahkim-13] Djebli, Moktar (2012). "Taḥkīm". In P. Bearman; Th. Bianquis; C.E. Bosworth; E. van Donzel; W.P. Heinrichs (eds.). Encyclopaedia of Islam (2nd ed.). Brill. doi:10.1163/1573-3912_islam_SIM_7311.

[14] Dan Cohn-Sherbok (1997). Hick, John (ed.). Islam in a World of Diverse Faiths Islam in a World of Diverse Faiths Library of Philosophy and Religion. Springer. p. 158. ISBN 1349253243. Retrieved 8 August 2024.

[EI10-hendricks-15] Shaykh Seraj Hendricks. The Kharijites and Their Impact on Contemporary Islam 1.

[16] Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. p. 197.

[17] Sizgorich, Thomas (2009). Violence and Belief in Late Antiquity: Militant Devotion in Christianity and Islam. University of Pennsylvania Press. pp. 206–207. ISBN 0812241134. Retrieved 8 August 2024.

[OEIW-18] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f John Alden Williams; Justin Corfield (2009). "Khawārij". In John L. Esposito (ed.). The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Islamic World. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195305135.

[EoQ-19] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Francesca, Ersilia (2006). "Khārijīs". In Jane Dammen McAuliffe (ed.). Encyclopaedia of the Qurʾān. Brill. doi:10.1163/1875-3922_q3_EQCOM_00103.

[Kharijite_Political_Influences_in_Medieval_Berbery-21] J. T. Brown 1963, pp. 11–16

[FOOTNOTEClarke2013510-22] Clarke 2013, p. 510.

[23] Wilkinson, John C. (2014). "Ibadism. Some Reconsiderations of its Origins and Early Development". In Ziaka, Angeliki (ed.). On Ibadism. Germany: Georg Olms Verlag AG. p. 43. ISBN 978-3-487-14882-3.

[24] Abou El Fadl, Khaled (2004), Cohen, Joshua; Chasman, Deborah (eds.), Islam and the challenge of democracy, Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press, ISBN 978-0-691-11938-0

[Said_Ruslan-25] Hakim, Saifudin (2021). "Mengenal Pokok-Pokok Aqidah Kaum Khawarij (Bag. 1)". Muslim.or.id (in Indonesian). Muslim.or.id. Retrieved 20 December 2021. Diraasaatun fil Bid'ati wal Mubtadi'in by Dr. Muhammad Sa'id Ruslan

[val3-26] Hoffman, Valerie Jon (2012). The Essentials of Ibadi Islam. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press. ISBN 9780815650843.

[27] John L. Esposito, ed. (2014). "Ibadis". The Oxford Dictionary of Islam. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Archived from the original on August 20, 2017.

[PEIPT-28] Keith Lewinstein, Racha (2013). "Ibadis". In Gerhard Böwering; Patricia Crone (eds.). The Princeton Encyclopedia of Islamic Political Thought. Princeton University Press.

[memory-187-29] Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. pp. 187–188.

[memory-193-30] Valerie J. Hoffman (2009). J. E. Lindsay; J. Armajani (eds.). Historical Memory and Imagined Communities: Modern Ibāḍī Writings on Khārijism. Vol. Historical Dimensions of Islam. Princeton: Darwin Press. pp. 193–195.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[Notes 1]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]

[25]

[26]

[27]

[28]

[29]