Second Thomas Shoal laser incident

Second Thomas Shoal laser incident
	Part of South China Sea disputes
	; CCG 5205 pointing a laser at BRP Malapascua
Date	February 6, 2023
Location	Second Thomas Shoal, South China Sea
Belligerents
Philippines	China
Units involved
Philippine Coast Guard BRP Malapascua;	China Coast Guard CCG 5205;

On February 6, 2023, the China Coast Guard and Philippine Coast Guard had an encounter near the Second Thomas Shoal, one of the features of the Spratly Islands which is subject to a wider dispute in the South China Sea.

The Second Thomas Shoal is claimed by multiple countries, including China and the Philippines. The latter controls the feature by having grounded the BRP Sierra Madre on the shoal.

The BRP Malapascua of the Philippine Coast Guard was heading towards the shoal for a rotation and rotation and resupply mission for the BRP Sierra Madre crew when CCG 5205 of the China Coast Guard blocked the Filipino coast guard ship to act what it views as an intrusion of the Philippine vessel and aimed a green laser light towards it. The Philippine side alleged the laser was "military grade" and caused its crew to suffer from temporary blindness, which China denies. The incident led to the Philippines filing a diplomatic protest.

Incident

According to the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG), the BRP Malapascua was aiding the Philippine Navy in conducting a rotation and resupply (RoRE) mission on February 6, 2023, when a ship from the China Coast Guard (CCG) with the with bow number 5205 deliberate blocked the coast guard ship from delivering food and supply to the crew of the grounded BRP Sierra Madre at the Philippines-controlled Second Thomas Shoal.^[1]

BRP Malapascua was 10 nautical miles (19 km; 12 mi) away from Second Thomas Shoal when the CCG vessel was spotted 4 nautical miles (7.4 km; 4.6 mi) ahead and was maneuvering from its left to block the PCG ship. The CCG ship beamed a green laser twice, which it claims to be of "military-grade", against the PCG ship caused its crew to suffer from temporary blindness. The PCG also added that the Chinese ship came close as 150 yards (140 m) to the right of BRP Malapascua.^[1]

BRP Malapascua then headed towards Nanshan Island to resume its maritime patrol and RoRE mission to stations within the Spratlys along with BRP Teresa Magbanua^[1]

Reactions

Philippines

On February 14, 2023, President Bongbong Marcos summoned Chinese Ambassador to the Philippines Huang Xilian over the incident to express concern over "the increasing frequency and intensity of actions" of China against the Philippine Coast Guard and Filipino fishermen. The Department of Foreign Affairs also filed a formal diplomatic protest.^[2]

Responding to an inquiry by the media, Marcos said that while the incident is clearly an "act of aggression", it is not enough reason to invoke the Mutual Defense Treaty with the United States.^[3]^[4]

The National Task Force for the West Philippine Sea said it would formulate new rules and procedures on how to deal with another potential laser-pointing and other encounters which it considers as harassment from China in the South China Sea.^[5]

China

China maintains defended its actions in the Second Thomas Shoal. It said it was only acting upon what they view as an "intrusion" of the Philippines side to its territory and insist that it was professional and restrained in dealing the issue.^[6]^[7] It says that the Philippine Coast Guard's account of the incident did "not reflect the truth". It also added that the light used was from a hand-held laser speed detector and hand-held greenlight pointer used to "measure the distance and speed of the Philippine vessel and signal directions to ensure navigation safety" and does not inflict damage on anything or anyone.^[8]

The Philippines' Department of Foreign Affairs in response told China to engage the Philippines in "truth and goodwill" standing by the account of the Philippine Coast Guard on what happened saying that there is "lack of congruence" between China's statements and what it believes to be the "actual events in the seas".^[6]^[7]

Ambassador Huang on February 7, 2023, would cite the "lack of communication" between his country and the Philippines over the incident and pushed for stronger dialogue mechanisms between the two countries to avoid similar incidents in the future.^[9]

Other countries

The United States Department of State issued a statement in support of the Philippines following the Second Thomas Shoal incident calling China's use of laser as "provocative and unsafe".^[10] Australia, Japan, and Germany likewise expressed concern over the incident.^[11]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c Valmonte, Kaycee (February 13, 2023). "Chinese Coast Guard aims laser at PCG vessel on resupply mission". The Philippine Star. Retrieved February 20, 2023.
^ Valente, Catherine; Tamayo, Bernadette; Baroña, Franco Jose (February 15, 2023). "Marcos summons Chinese envoy". The Manila Times. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ Flores, Helen (February 19, 2023). "… but laser incident not enough to activate MDT". The Philippine Star. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ Peralta-Malonzo, Third Anne (February 19, 2023). "Marcos not inclined to invoke Mutual Defense Treaty following Ayungin incident". Sunstar. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ Baroña, Franco Jose (February 19, 2023). "Task force formulates new rules to address sea harassment". The Manila Times. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ ^a ^b Rocamora, Joyce Ann (February 17, 2023). "DFA tells China to engage PH based on facts after laser-use row". Philippine News Agency. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ ^a ^b Del Callar, Michaela (February 16, 2023). "Philippines rejects China claim that use of laser pointer not meant to harm PCG crew". GMA News. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ "China says lasers for 'navigation safety', denies pointing at PH crew". GMA News. GMA Integrated News. February 16, 2023. Retrieved February 20, 2023.
^ "Chinese envoy cites 'lack of communication' in Ayungin laser incident, pushes for stronger mechanisms". CNN Philippines. February 17, 2023. Archived from the original on February 19, 2023. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
^ Price, Ned. "U.S. Support for the Philippines in the South China Sea". United States Department of State. Retrieved February 20, 2023.
^ "Japan, Australia, Germany raise concerns over China's use of laser vs. Philippine ship". GMA News. February 15, 2023. Retrieved February 20, 2023.

[aims-1] Valmonte, Kaycee (February 13, 2023). "Chinese Coast Guard aims laser at PCG vessel on resupply mission". The Philippine Star. Retrieved February 20, 2023.

[summons-2] Valente, Catherine; Tamayo, Bernadette; Baroña, Franco Jose (February 15, 2023). "Marcos summons Chinese envoy". The Manila Times. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[mdt-3] Flores, Helen (February 19, 2023). "… but laser incident not enough to activate MDT". The Philippine Star. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[sunstar-mdt-4] Peralta-Malonzo, Third Anne (February 19, 2023). "Marcos not inclined to invoke Mutual Defense Treaty following Ayungin incident". Sunstar. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[task-force-5] Baroña, Franco Jose (February 19, 2023). "Task force formulates new rules to address sea harassment". The Manila Times. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[dfa-tells-6] Rocamora, Joyce Ann (February 17, 2023). "DFA tells China to engage PH based on facts after laser-use row". Philippine News Agency. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[rejects-7] Del Callar, Michaela (February 16, 2023). "Philippines rejects China claim that use of laser pointer not meant to harm PCG crew". GMA News. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[8] "China says lasers for 'navigation safety', denies pointing at PH crew". GMA News. GMA Integrated News. February 16, 2023. Retrieved February 20, 2023.

[lack-of-comm-9] "Chinese envoy cites 'lack of communication' in Ayungin laser incident, pushes for stronger mechanisms". CNN Philippines. February 17, 2023. Archived from the original on February 19, 2023. Retrieved February 19, 2023.

[10] Price, Ned. "U.S. Support for the Philippines in the South China Sea". United States Department of State. Retrieved February 20, 2023.

[11] "Japan, Australia, Germany raise concerns over China's use of laser vs. Philippine ship". GMA News. February 15, 2023. Retrieved February 20, 2023.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]