Sinking of the ferry Neptune
| Date | February 16, 1993 |
|---|---|
| Location | Near Miragoane, Haiti |
| Cause | Conditions of the weather, ship, and crowd |
| Outcome | ~1,500 deaths out of ~2,000 passengers |
The sinking of the ferry Neptune, a Haitian commercial ship which regularly carried people and cargo from Jérémie to Port-au-Prince, occurred on the night of February 16, 1993. It capsized and sank off the coast of Miragoane, due to a mix of the passenger crowd's size and movement, and the conditions of the ship and weather.
Haiti's economic and political situation at the time allowed their ferry system to operate with no regulations, which contributed to the ship's large crowd size. When a heavy rainstorm hit the ship halfway through its journey, the ship started to pitch and roll, and the crowd panicked, going to one side of the ship. This caused the ship to capsize, and it eventually sunk. The accident likely caused 1,500 deaths out of 2,000 passengers, which would make it one of the worst maritime disasters in history. Search-and-rescue efforts were done mostly by the U.S. Coast Guard, though the efforts were less effective than they could have been, as it took two days for the sinking to be officially reported in Port-au-Prince.
Background
[edit]At the time of the Haitian ferry Neptune's sinking in 1993, ferries were a common transportation method in the country, as there was a lack of usable roads, transportation vehicles, and fuel for aircraft and buses. Many of these ferries were in poor conditions, and often caused deaths, due to accidents including engine failures.[1][2][3] After the 1991 coup in Haiti, an embargo was put against the country, which stopped Haitian import of goods including fuel and spare parts for ships.[3][4] Boat companies became "systematically permitted" to ignore government regulations.[4]
The Neptune regularly ran from the county's western port and agricultural production center of Jérémie to the capital of Port-au-Prince, 120 miles (190 km)[4] to 180 miles (290 km)[5] away. It ordinarily carried people and cargo (including cattle) brought on by poorer passengers to be sold in Port-au-Prince.[1][5][6] The boat was 150 feet (46 m)[1] or 163 feet (50 m)[4] long, steel-hulled, and had three decks.[1][6] It was aging, rusting, and poorly maintained.[2][6][7] The captain's name was reported as either Julio Antoine[3][4] or Benjamin St. Clair.[1][2][6] It was owned by Carmin Magliore, who was on the boat when it sank, but survived.[4] It was one of two ships which regularly ran that route,[6] which took 12 to 18 hours.[1][3] Tickets costed $7 in 1993 U.S. dollars.[4] The Tampa Bay Times described the bay in between the cities as "treacherous".[6] Days before the ferry's sinking, it was witnessed having no lifeboats. Survivors of the sinking said it had no emergency gear, including radios.[1]
Ever since the 1991 coup, there was a trend of Haitians hijacking ships in order to sail to the United States and seek asylum there. This was in response to the county's economic situation and political repression.[1][3][6] The U.S. Coast Guard would attempt to destroy these ships and bring their occupants back to Haiti. This caused Neptune's regular Tuesday run to be delayed for several weeks in 1993. According to a Haitian official, this led to overcrowding during the ship's fatal journey, due to demand built up over the weeks.[2] In addition, the ship often carried more people than its limit of roughly 650.[1] Local ferries at the time would cram as many people on board at one time to earn more money.[6]
Sinking
[edit]On the night of February 16, 1993, the ship was doing its regular run, carrying hundreds of passengers.[1][2] The number has been reported as between 800 or 850 at its lowest, and 2,000 at its highest.[1][6] However, 800 is an unlikely, conservative estimate. The number is not exact as the ship carried no passenger lists.[1] 750 or 800 tickets were sold for this particular trip, but after a later ferry had cancelled that day, at least 150 people overwhelmed guards and crammed onto the ship.[2][4][5] A survivor said there were at least 100 children on board, and that all of them died.[6]
According to a U.S. Coast Guard representative, halfway through its journey, the ship ran into a heavy rainstorm. The rain and wind (potentially in the form of a squall[6]) caused the boat to pitch and roll. In a panic, many people rushed to one side of the ship, and others rushed to the top deck. Officials, including the captain, said the passengers going to one side caused the ship to start capsizing.[1][2] A passenger said the captain tried to get people to move to the other side to keep it balanced.[6] The tipping caused people and cargo to spill into the ocean. Some of the people in the water drowned, and some held onto dead animal carcasses, crates of soda, and other objects.[1][3] Some of them would hold on for up to 31 hours.[3] On the top deck, there was a crowd crush, which caused the deck to collapse onto the hundreds of people below it.[1] At 1 a.m., the ship finished rolling on its side, and sunk off the coast of Miragoane.[1][6][8] Survivors said the crew gave no help to the passengers when this happened.[1]
Aftermath
[edit]Afterwards, the sea surrounding the shipwreck site was littered with bodies and debris. The disaster was not officially reported until the morning of February 18; there was a lack of communications between the area where survivors swam to and Port-au-Prince, as there were bad roads and a "scant" telephone network.[1][2] This delay led to a less effective rescue effort.[2] The Haitian government offered condolences to the victims' families, and made no further comment.[6] Repairs were done to the other ship that took the Neptune's route.[3]
The Haitian navy was almost inoperative, and only two small motor boats could assist in the search-and-rescue operation.[1] American C-130 airplanes, helicopters, and two to five U.S. Coast Guard cutters (including the Dauntless and Padre) searched the water for survivors and bodies.[1][3][5][6] Another Coast Guard spokesman said the cutters picked up so many bodies that they stopped counting how many victims there were.[1] Some bodies were sent to a morgue in Port-au-Prince.[3]
Many passengers, including the captain and Magliore, swam to shore and arrived there by late Wednesday.[1][4][6] The captain was brought by police to Port-au-Prince for questioning.[6]
Survivor and death tolls
[edit]There have been different numbers of survivors and deaths reported. Late into 18 February, the head of the Haitian Red Cross said 285 survivors had been found, and said that while further survivors may be found, he expected at least 1,500 to be dead.[1] The Coast Guard also estimated 1,500.[2] 134 bodies of women and children were brought by the Coast Guard to Port-au-Prince on the 18th.[6] By February 19, around 285 people had swum ashore.[5] They were found in a 30-mile (48 km) stretch which included Miragoane, Petit Goave, and Leogane.[1][2] 170 to 200 bodies were reported recovered on February 20,[3][4] yet 285 was still the survivor toll by the 20th.[3] The number of people found holding onto objects in the water was later reported as 300.[9] The Independent estimated the death toll at 1,800. They wrote that if the toll was around that number, it would have been the deadliest maritime disaster since the 1987 ferry incident in the Philippines.[5] In later years, the minimum number was reported as 500[9][10] or 900,[11] and the maximum number as 700 (though the 1,500 estimate still exists[7]).[12][13]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x Freed, Kenneth (1993-02-19). "Hundreds Dead in Sinking of Overloaded Haiti Ferry : Disaster: Only 285 survivors are found from 2,000 believed aboard the boat when it capsized in a storm". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k French, Howard W. (1993-02-19). "Hundreds Are Lost As Crowded Ferry Capsizes Off Haiti". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l "Of 800 to 1,200 Aboard Haitian Ferry, 285 Lived". The New York Times. Reuters. 1993-02-20. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j Beard, David (February 20, 1993). "Bad Transport System Blamed In Haiti Ferry Deaths". The Seattle Times. Retrieved March 10, 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f Cornwell, Rupert (February 19, 1993). "Hundreds drowned in Haiti disaster". The Independent. Retrieved March 10, 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r "Ferry sinks off Haiti; hundreds die". Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ a b McFadden, Christopher (2023-05-08). "11 of the worst shipwrecks of all time by death count". Interesting Engineering. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ "The Philippines: A record of shipping disasters". BBC News. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ a b Volpe, Nicole (September 9, 1997). "Hundreds Drown as Haitian Ferry Sinks". The Washington Post. Retrieved March 10, 2024.
- ^ Jansen, Bart (April 16, 2014). "10 worst ferry disasters worldwide". USA Today. Retrieved March 10, 2024.
- ^ Curtis, Gene (2011-02-17). "Way back when: Today in history". Tulsa World. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
- ^ "Overcrowded Ferry Sinks Hundreds Feared Drowned". New York Daily News. September 9, 1997. Retrieved March 10, 2024.
- ^ "Haiti ferry disaster may have claimed 400 lives". The Independent. 1997-09-08. Retrieved 2024-03-10.