Horizontal collaboration
Horizontal collaboration (French: Collaboration horizontale, collaboration féminine or collaboration sentimentale) referred to the romantic or sexual relationship many women in France had or allegedly had with members of the German occupation forces after the Fall of France in 1940. The existence of these liaisons had been a major reason for young men to join the French Resistance.[1] After the Liberation of France from German occupation, such women were often punished for collaboration with the German occupiers.
After the war, throughout France, women accused of collaboration had their heads shaved.[2] These women were referred to as "femme tondue" (shaven women) and were easily identifiable.[3] In many of the 20,000 cases, the women in question had performed only professional services for the occupying Germans, rather than being engaged in sexual relationships with them.[4] Due to the head-shaving in public spaces being used to punish women thought to be collaborators, and the presence of many foreign photographers in post-war France, thousands of photos exist of women being subjected to this punishment.[5]
"Collaboration horizontale" is believed to have produced 200,000 French babies with German fathers.[6] Since 2009 Germany has offered these children of "the other bank of the Rhine" citizenship, after French foreign minister Bernard Kouchner lobbied for their recognition.[7] The same phenomenon and later punishments occurred in other parts of Europe that were occupied by Germany during the war.
Horizontal collaboration outside of France
[edit]Horizontal collaboration was also seen and condemned in other countries occupied by Germany during World War II, such as in Serbia[8] and in Norway, where the so-called Norwegian tyskertøs (German sluts) included thousands who actively participated in the Lebensborn program and others, such as the mother of ABBA member Anni-Frid Lyngstad, who independently had children with a German soldier.[9] Rather than shaving their heads, women accused of horizontal collaboration in Norway were subjected to public exile and even arrest or internment. Any children that came from relationships between the local women and German soldiers were also considered part of the betrayal, and were equally exiled - considered illegitimate or bastards; Lyngstad's mother sent her to Sweden to avoid this. In both Norway and Serbia, horizontal collaboration was seen as a betrayal of one's own country during the war, and was often treated as an act of aggression.
In October of 2018, Norwegian Prime Minister Erna Solberg publicly apologized to the tyskertøser and their children for the treatment they received following the liberation.[10] Neither France nor Serbia have followed suit in terms of an official apology.
In popular media
[edit]In Hiroshima mon amour (1959), the female protagonist is revealed to have been shaven as punishment for collaboration horizontale as a result of her relationship with a German soldier.[11] The film visually linked the suffering of women forcibly shaved after D-Day with the loss of hair experienced by survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.[12]
The phenomenon also inspired the 2010 film Collaboration horizontale, a documentary exploring what happened to the baby shown in the photo of The Shaved Woman of Chartres.[13]
In the 2000 film Malèna, a woman in wartime Sicily is punished for her beauty and her liaisons with German soldiers by the local women ripping off her clothes, beating her and shaving her hair.[14]
In the fourth episode of the 2001 series Band of Brothers multiple women can be seen shaved with a black swastika on their forehead for collaborating with the Nazis.[15]
The 2019 graphic novel Horizontal Collaboration tells the story of a liaison between a French woman and a German soldier in wartime France.[16]
In the TV series Interview with the Vampire, in 1948, the character Madeleine is shunned for a tryst she had with a Nazi lieutenant during the occupation of Paris.
See also
[edit]- The Shaved Woman of Chartres (1944 photograph)
References
[edit]- ^ Crowdy, Terry (2007). French Resistance Fighter: France's Secret Army (PDF). Oxford: Osprey Publishing. p. 8. ISBN 978-1-84603-076-5. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2018-07-19. Retrieved 2020-09-14.
- ^ Fabrice Virgili (1995). "Les "tondues" à la Libération :le corps des femmes, enjeu d'une réaproppriation". Clio. Femmes, genre, histoire (1). doi:10.4000/clio.518.
- ^ Virgili, Fabrice (1995-04-01). "Les « tondues » à la Libération :le corps des femmes, enjeu d'une réaproppriation". Clio. Femmes, Genre, Histoire (in French) (1). doi:10.4000/clio.518. ISSN 1252-7017.
- ^ Marc Bergère (September 2004). "Tous les milieux sociaux ont été visés". Historia (693). Paris: 56–60.
- ^ Alison Moore, History, Memory and Trauma in Photography of the Tondues: visuality of the Vichy past through the silent image of women. Gender and History 17 (3), November 2005, 657-681.
- ^ Shapin, Stephen (20 September 2013). "Book Review: 'Brave Genius' by Sean B. Carroll". Wall Street Journal.
- ^ "Les "enfants de la guerre" reconnus par Berlin". Libération. 20 February 2009.
- ^ Škodrić, Ljubinka (2015-12-31). "Intimate Relations between Women and the German Occupiers in Serbia 1941-1944". Cahiers balkaniques (in French). 43. doi:10.4000/ceb.8589. ISSN 0290-7402.
- ^ Ericsson, Kjersti (2016-03-09). Women in War: Examples from Norway and Beyond. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-134-77632-0.
- ^ Minister, The Office of the Prime (2018-10-23). "Official apology to girls and women who had relationships with German soldiers during the Second World War". Government.no. Retrieved 2021-04-26.
- ^ Carmen M. Cusack (3 November 2015). HAIR AND JUSTICE: Sociolegal Significance of Hair in Criminal Justice, Constitutional Law, and Public Policy. Charles C Thomas Publisher. pp. 64–. ISBN 978-0-398-09096-8.
- ^ Amal Amireh; Lisa Suhair Majaj (1 May 2014). Going Global: The Transnational Reception of Third World Women Writers. Routledge. pp. 298–. ISBN 978-1-317-95409-5.
- ^ "Collaboration horizontale". IMDB.
- ^ Malena (2000) - IMDb, retrieved 2022-11-12
- ^ "In the show Band of Brothers we are shown numerous woman who had slept with German soldiers while their heads are being shaved after a Dutch town is liberated by American Soldiers. Similarly, we are shown women whose head was shaved with a baby. What happened to these women and their children?". 3 February 2019.