Anarcha Westcott

Anarcha Westcott (c. 1828 – unknown) was an enslaved woman who underwent a series of experimental surgical procedures conducted by physician J. Marion Sims, without the use of anesthesia, to treat a combination of vesicovaginal fistula and rectovaginal fistula. Sims's medical experimentation with Anarcha and other enslaved women, and its role in the development of modern gynaecology, has generated controversy among medical historians.

In the 21st century, Anarcha has become a heroine for many Black women.

Background

For many years, little was known about Anarcha, and the only source of her existence was Sims's writings; as she was illiterate (by law), most information came from Sims' records of his experiments. She first appears in the autobiography of J. Marion Sims as a "little mulatto girl" living in the doctor's house in Mount Meigs, Alabama; as he says on the following page, "a little negro girl would sleep in the room with me, and hand me a drink of water occasionally."

Anarcha next turns up as "a young colored woman, about seventeen years of age, well developed" belonging to a Mr. Wescott [sic], who lived a mile from Sims' house, at that time in Montgomery, Alabama. Sims was called in to assist after her labor lasted three days. Whereas Anarcha's "colleague" Betsey, on whom Sims would operate for a similar problem, had "married last year", no source comments on how Anarcha became pregnant, so the unidentified father of her stillborn child may well have been Mr. Wescott ("a kind-hearted man") or Dr. Sims.

Author J.C. Hallman's book Say Anarcha (2023) is based on many never-before-seen sources revealing the reality of Anarcha's life, and her eventual fate. Hallman's work eventually revealed her gravesite, and he managed to locate living descendants of Anarcha and her husband, Lorenzo. Anarcha's descendants include the president of Dillard University, Dr. Rochelle Ford.[1] "It’s a blessing to know that generations later, our family has CEOs of major corporations, presidents of universities, vice presidents (in business), attorneys and educators," Ford said. "From slavery until today, we continue to contribute to America."

Experimental surgery

After the stillbirth, Anarcha was brought back to Sims because she had several unhealed tears in her vagina and rectum – a vesicovaginal fistula and rectovaginal fistula. These tears meant she had no control over her urine and feces, which caused her to have excruciating pain from her uncontrollable bowel and urine movements flowing through her open wounds. Being unable to control her urine and feces led to infections, inflamed tissue, and odor.

Sims performed 30 experimental, operations without anesthesia on Anarcha before successfully closing the fistula and tears. During the procedures, Anarcha was given no anesthesia, which had recently become available. Following the procedures, Sims administered opium, which was then an accepted method to treat pain. The experimental procedures that Sims performed on Anarcha and other enslaved people revolutionized gynecological surgery; the technique Sims developed became the first ever treatment for vesicovaginal fistulae.

On December 21, 1856, Anacha [sic], age 32, was admitted to Sims' Woman's Hospital in New York, with the notation that she stayed about a month and was discharged in January 1857 as cured. Her enslaver was William Lewis Maury, U.S. Navy, Caroline County, Virginia. The circumstances of her trip to New York are unknown.

A tombstone for an "Annacay" [sic], wife of Lorenzo Jackson, was found by chance in King George County, Virginia (adjacent to Caroline County). In the 1870 Census, her name is spelled Anaky Jackson, and on her death record, Ankey. The death date on the Vital Statistics does not match that on her tombstone (1869/70). Filmmaker Carples concludes that all of these are the same Anarcha that Sims treated in Alabama. If she was 32 in 1856, she was born in 1824, and pregnant at 13 when she first was treated by Sims.

Remembrance

In 2015, author J.C. Hallman became obsessed with finding Anarcha. He published articles about Sims and Anarcha in Harper's Magazine, the Montgomery Advertiser, and The Baffler, and his work to discover Anarcha's final resting place is featured in Josh Carples' documentary film Remembering Anarcha. Hallman is working on a book entitled The Anarcha Quest, based on the first archival evidence of Anarcha's life that did not come from Sims's own accounts. The book was published in 2023 as Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women's Health.

Say Anarcha went on to be praised by The New York Times as "a truly astounding tale...compelling and well-researched" and "an important book [that] deserves to be read widely." The Brooklyn Rail called the book "an instant classic" and "a new masterpiece" and noted that "Hallman had done what no scholar had previously succeeded in doing, namely unearthing information about Anarcha independent of Sims’s tendentious accounts of her life." Publisher's Weekly praised the book in a starred review as "innovative and riveting...a must-read," and Booklist, also a starred review, called the book "commanding and affecting...and grimly relevant."

One of the principal discoveries in Say Anarcha was that Anarcha never took the name "Anarcha Westcott." She died with the surname Jackson, and the name on her gravestone, in Virginia, is "Annacay Jackson."

Hallman has also located the living descendants of Anarcha and her husband, Lorenzo.[2] Efforts are underway to ensure that her gravesite is properly protected and memoirialized.

A small statue of Anarcha Westcott was erected by protestors near the statue of Sims on the grounds of the Alabama State Capitol. It was quickly stolen.

Feminist hardcore punk band War on Women wrote a song called "Anarcha" on their 2018 album "Capture the Flag", honouring Anarcha Westcott. It denounces the actions of Sims and their impact on Anarcha and the other two named women he is known to have experimented on, as well as the more general context of men imposing their will on the bodies of women, as a way of remembering all the other women who suffered similar fates and whose names were ignored and forgotten at the time.

In 2021, artist Michelle Browder toured the country raising funds and asking for donations of discarded metal objects, which she would weld to construct a 15-foot memorial to Anarcha Westcott and two other women (Betsey and Lucy) who were experimented on by Sims. The work, the Mothers of Gynecology Monument, was completed in San Francisco and the sculpture was erected in Montgomery, Alabama, as part of a wider campus project to bring awareness to the Mothers of Gynecology Movement.

Media

• Hallman, J.C. (June 6, 2023). Say Anarcha: A Young Woman, a Devious Surgeon, and the Harrowing Birth of Modern Women's Health.
• Vedantam, Shankar (February 16, 2016). "Remembering Anarcha, Lucy, and Betsey: The Mothers of Modern Gynecology". Hidden Brain. National Public Radio.
• Thom, Robert, Illustration of Dr. J. Marion Sims with Anarcha
• “Behind the Sheet”, by Charly Evon Simpson, "reframes modern gynecology’s origin story, demonstrating how these women supported one another through suffering, and challenges the dominant historical narrative that centers Sims."
• Outdoor painting of Anarcha, Lucy and Betsey in downtown Montgomery. Artist?
• https://www.pbs.org/newshour/tag/mothers-of-gynecology

Poetry

• Godley, Joanne (2021). "A Herstory of Pain". Massachusetts Review. 62 (1): 33–42. doi:10.1353/mar.2021.0006. S2CID 234141629.
• Christina, Dominique (2018). Anarcha Speaks : A History in Poems. Beacon Press. ISBN 9780807009215.
• Maples, Kwoya Fagin (2018). Mend : poems. Lexington, Kentucky: University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 9780813176284.
• Judd, Bettina (2014). Patients : poems. Black Lawrence Press. ISBN 9781625579232.
• Judd, Bettina (2013). "The Researcher Discovers Anarcha, Betsey, Lucy". Meridians: Feminism, Race, Transnationalism. 11 (2): 238–239 – via Project MUSE.
• Jarrett, T. J. (2014). "Anarcha: J. Marion Sims Opens My Body for the Thirty-First Time". Virginia Quarterly Review. 90 (3): 52 – via Project MUSE.

See also

• List of enslaved people
• List of monuments to African Americans
• Slavery in the United States

Further reading

• Sims, J. Marion (January 1852). "On the Treatment of Vesico-Vaginal Fistula". American Journal of the Medical Sciences: 59–82.